False statements online: what you can do
A false statement of fact that harms your reputation is defamation. An opinion is not, however harsh.
Fact or opinion
"They stole my deposit" is a claim of fact. "Worst contractor in town" is an opinion. Only the first can be defamation, and only if it is false.
The website
U.S. law generally does not hold a website responsible for what its users post. So you ask the site under its own rules against false or harassing content.
The person who posted
They are responsible. A calm letter asking them to remove it, listing each false statement, often works.
Court
If it is costing you real money, small claims court can handle it in many states. The time limit is short, often one year.
Be careful
Legal threats over true statements or opinions can backfire, and in many states they can cost you the other side's legal fees.
This is general information, not legal advice. A takedown notice is a sworn statement: send one only for work you own.